Ok here is a question. Sometimes you offer a settlement just to not have to deal with the company any further, in the wording of the letter it states that:
this payment constitutes payment in full of the account, no other monies owed, account closed with a zero balance.
So how could a company file a 1099c if there is no remaining balance? There must be a way to word the settlement to state that what you are paying is what is owed and nothing further is owed. If the agreement was that both parties agreed that say $500 is owed, rather then the $800 they were trying to say is owed...then couldn't you avoid the 1099c that way? If they then file it, you could goto the IRS and tell them that the $800 was never owed, that only $500 was owed.....