Pull your credit report and see if they are reporting you. If not then all is well. If they are, you can dispute it with the credit bureaus and see if it will come off.
Before I paid the money, I would've asked the CA if they were reporting, and if so, negotiated removal from your credit report. Of course, get everything in writing. THEN, I would've paid it. Once you pay the bill, you lessen your negotiating power.