mybe this will help you decide on if settlement is right for you. In my experience i knew that when i went on my maturnity leave my job was not going to be there when i got back. and even if it was i couldnt afford to go to work anyhow due to daycare, insurances, etc(long story it was costing me more to go to work than to stay home) My husband and i were barely making ends meet as it was let alone a unexpected new baby and his needs.
This is what you need to take into consideration. can you pay x amount for a long period of time? are you confident nothing is going to change in the x amount of years till you are done with consolidation? If you can swing it it is your best option.
but if you cannot and are unsure as to if you are going to be able to meet these payments, or are expecting a loss in income soon, settlement is best. It will hurt your credit temporarily because you stop paying them. But when you are done you can get back on track with your credit pretty quickly with these debts now paid and keeping current with your new ones.
Choose this choice before bk. so if you can swing counseling do that, if not settlement is your next best option, and if that fails your doomed for bk.