The relationship between Capital One and Encore is this.
Capital One DOES NOT do any of their own collections. They contract Encore and Asset Acceptance to do that for them under their own name(Capital One). Have you ever noticed no matter HOW hard you press they will not confirm they are with Capital One, but also will not tell you who they really work for, they just keep saying "collections" over and over.
In this instance they are basically contract employees of Capital One, working under their name, as such in this particular instance the fdcpa does not apply to them, as they would be considered "Original Creditor". It is not right but it is a loop hole in the laws that has been allowed to remain.
Note to Encore manager: Don't get into the "first party, third party" thing. The laws do not recognize 1st and 3rd partry. The FDCPA defines only "Original Creditor" or "collector". Saying, 1st party, 3rd party, etc is an attempt to blur the lines and skirt around the intent and spirit of the law, especially considering Encore does both for the same client (however when they send account to Encore's 3rd party collections , then they ARE governed by FDCPA).
I agree with you assertion that this has been used by some as a stall tactic, however, if collection agencies would actually comply with this important step, rather than play games, not validate, or send accounts off to another CA, then you could get past this point and right to doing what your are hired to do, collect the account. The truth of the matter is most collection agencies can not validate, and are reluctant to go to their client and request this information, as it shows they cannot necessarily perform the service they were hired to do without taxing the resources of the client. Eventually the client may figure they could do it them selves and enjoy all the money they are entitled to rather than having to split it with the CA.
AS for you comment about a Cease and desist letter not being honored because it is sent to the wrong office, this is the exact reason Collection Agencies establish multiple offices. This is also a stall tactic on the part of the CA to prevent consumers from exercising their legal rights within the 30 days as allowed under the FDCPA. The office actually handling the debt should be CLEARLY listed on the Dunning letter, not jumbled with two or three different offices.
Encore (or any Collection agency) should readily give that information with out hesitation, however most won't hopeing the consumer sends their dispute or validation request to the wrong office so they can turn around and say "we never received it" or "it went to the wrong place, send it again, but your thirty days is past, we assume the debt is valid". Nice games.
I also notice you never explained how I could go about getting a zero balance letter form Encore? The office collecting on my sprint bill was the Olathe Kansas ( and where I sent the payment) but when I call back to get the letter, no one know anything and tells me to call the Las Vegas Office, I call there, they don't do that. I paid what I was supposed to, why wont Encore put it in witting?
You have shared a wealth of information and your participation here is always welcome.