Well, That answers everything. If all of the bill collectors are as illiterate as this one, that explains why they just can't seem to get things straight. Here is my issue: In 2004, Capital One gave someone in Hannibal, New York, a credit card in my name. That person charged $500 on it. At that point, I had not lived in New York for over 4 years. For that matter, I was deployed to a remote area Iraq the entire time the credit card was active. I spoke with Capital One about it when i found it on my credit report. Soon after that, it dissappeared off my credit report for a few months, now it has come back from the dead and Pinnacle is harrassing me about it. No, SHYTBAG, it is not mine. Take some of the money you are getting paid and get an education.