kfstaff24,
You are correct about the evolution of the industry, but not facing the reason. The reason that there has been a growth of PDL store is based on demand. That is also the reason that there must be an evolution of the product. Do you really believe that if the state or federal governments completely eliminated PDL's that society and the consumer would be in a better position? If you answer anything other than no, you are living in a sheltered world.
The product was created when the banks began growing in the late 80's and early 90's. This growth resulted in the "my banker will help me" mindset changing to "my bank only looks at the bottom line". The change meant that a person could no longer walk into their bank, speak to thier banker and get a couple hundred dollars to tide them over. The product was not new, just moved from one entity to another. With this move, there were regulations that were put into place to protect both the consumer and the lender, while being overseen by the state in which the PDL operated.
Fastforward to today. The demand is now higher than ever. The internet was invented (by Al Gore!) and became a mainstream method for many things including PDL's. The states are now getting a bright idea to get rid of the "evil Payday Loan Stores". Unfotrunately, they cannot see the forest thru the trees. By creating laws that outlaw/ban/eliminate legal lenders, they are forcing the consumer to go to the one place that has caused more issues that the banks or legal lenders, the internet. The industry will evolve and the consumer will now begin to give their banking information to some anonymous company at the other end of who knows where and when they get into trouble, the state cannot and will not do anything to assist because it is illegal in your state. They cannot contact the offending company due to no registration, they cannot get your money back due to no authority and in the end, the consumer will suffer. Studies have been completed in the states that were "victorious" against the legal lenders and the results were increased BK's, defaults, late payments and an increase in NSF fees received by the banks.
The facts from the industry are that approximately 95% of the customers pay thier advances on time and have no issues with the service. The flip side of that is that the 5% that don't tend to have a large number that do not want to acccept responsibility for thier situation and inturn blame thier poor management of thier finances on everyone else. They are also the ones that "scream" the loudest and then get heard. They then fulfill the prophecy of the "exception becomes the rule". Kind of like here, since this forum attracts people that have had issues with PDL's, which is a small sample of the "real world", then everyone in the "real world" must have the same issue.
In the end, are there bad lenders out there? Yes!!
Are they the exception or the rule? Currently, the exception.
Will the exception become the rule? If the current trend continues and more states eliminate the product, the "bottom feeders" will have more food and get bigger and bigger with no regulation to control them in the world of the internet.
Make yourself educated on the products and lenders out there and go with a LEGAL lender if you need a loan. In the case of the OP, if you need to borrow, I would feel comfortable with Advance America for 2 reasons, they are licensed and they are a publically traded company with many checks and balances to protect the shareholders and customers.