Cash Central and Speedy Cash are your only licensed lenders.
You need to close your account. Then call the 2 licensed lenders and set up alternate payment arrangements. Do NOT give them (or anyone) your new account info. Use a prepaid debit card or mail money orders to pay them off. See if they will set you up on an affordable extended payment plan.
After you have a new account, send the unlicensed lender letter (email is fine) to the others. File complaints with the Attorney General of AL, the FTC, the state of AL Banking Dept and the BBB if you like.
We suggest repaying the principal of the loan only. If you've already paid that in fees/rollovers/interest, then you're done. You can also request a refund of any overpayment if you like. If you still owe something, request a mailing address and be clear that you will only pay via money order.
You can find a sample letter and read about many others' experiences
here.