First thing to do is get your account closed to secure your money. This will ensure they can't and won't continue making withdrawls from your account. Make sure that you don't give out your new account information to ANYONE. They will contact you with threats, blah, blah, blah. Failure to pay a PDL is not a criminal case and therefore you can't be put in jail - doens't mean they won't threaten, but bottom line is they can't do it. The PDL's will attempt to handle your accounts in house first, before collections or atleast that was my experience with them.
The only legal PD companies in KY are "check cashiers" store fronts. You need to make sure if you have any of them they are taken care of. All internet PDL's are illegal in KY. Because internet PDL's are illegal in KY, they may turn you over to a collection agency but all you need to do is request validation of the debt and request they itemize how they came up with the amount you owe. Send a C & D letter - although due to the fact they are illegal may not follow it. You can fight anything that shows up on your credit report from an illegal PDL and it should be fairly easy to have removed - I haven't gotten this far in the process yet.
Yes, morally you are obligated to repay the principle only. Any fees paid to this point can be deducted from the principle amount of the loan, also - that may help you.
I understand being scared eveyone here has been there. The PDL's count on you being scared and will attempt to work that to their advantage.
Shazzers has a great sticky posted for dealing with illegal PDL's.
I thought of using a debt consolidation company like Langhorne but because the internet PDL's are illegal in KY, it would have been a total waste of money. Money that could have been applied to the principle amounts of my loans.
I've only dealt with 500 fast cash on your lists of lenders.
Word of advice just ignore the calls and don't discuss anything with them verbally other than telling them all communication needs to be made with USPS or email so you have documentation of all conversation.