Thank you all for saving me a bunch of time. As mentioned before, a practice like this should be illegal. I can't speak for anyone else, but the only reason I have the alert is that my personal information has been compromised (a stolen laptop from a state employee who should not have taken the laptop out of the office).
I wonder how may folks that don't get the credit alerts that we get will just get these new cards and start racking up credit balances with this unethical company.
Citibank should be ashamed, because if this is not an illegal practice, it certainly is unethical. My guess is that they will get their share of bad karma from this deceptive scheme.