Dear SoapLady, In 1988, I cosigned a law loan with Sallie Mae of $12,500 for a person on my faculty. (big mistake) I never paid anything on the loan and she paid as little as possible, with the result that in June of 2008, the loan was about to go into default at $17,000. At that point Sallie Mae agreed to accept $9,500 from me to settle the account. I have a letter from the debt collection agency confirming this fact and Sallie Mae also has a record of my June 2008 payment.
However, Sallie Mae never closed the account (I found this out by chance from a form mailing.) After two months of my nagging them, they finally closed the account in November of 2009. During that time about $1200 of interest had accumulated. I realize I will get stuck with the cancellation of debt as income. And also that I will never get any credit for the $9,500 paid, because it was credited to 2008.
My question is: Why should I pay my tax rate x the $1200 accumulated through Sallie Mae's error? Underpaying taxes is not a solution, nor, unfortunately, is suing Sallie Mae. They made a federal tax error themselves and will not want to admit it. I know this amount is not much in the big scheme of things, but it is the last straw! Could I ask the Feds if they want an amended return for 2008?
Thanks for any ideas,
Suzanne