What should I do? Payday loan issue

I am going through the same situation. My suggestion is talk to the lending company and let them know about your present financial conditions. They want to get their money back. Assure them that you are keen to clear the account provided if some extensions can be offered to you. Cash Store seems to be local storefront lender. They might be pretty much easier to work with in comparison to internet lenders. You need to know their moves before you can think about other possible options.

I'm not sure if they are the same, but I had a loan out with The Cash Store in Wisconsin and they have been accepting my payments through my debt management program. I get calls every once in a while from the collection agency asking if I'm able to pay the balance off and I just keep telling them no and that my payments will keep coming.

Breezy..since this is most likely a store front lender, they are probably legal in your state. Your better off calling them and making some sort of arrangements with them before they try to sue you.
Most of those places will work with you, as long as you make good on your promise to pay.