logo

Debtconsolidationcare.com - the USA consumer forum

winning regarding FCRA/FDCPA violations?

Date: Wed, 01/07/2009 - 09:06

Submitted by smo65d11
on Wed, 01/07/2009 - 09:06

Posts: 1467 Credits: [Donate]

Total Replies: 90


Does anyone have any success (or failure!) stories they'd like to share regarding winning filed lawsuits against collection agencies who have violated the FCRA/FDCPA? I am not just talking about those who have sent Intent To Serve letters in order to scare them into it, I'm talking about those who have actually gone to court because the Collection Agency wouldn't admit any wrong- doing.
Thank you!


they are off! Well, of Experian anyway, for some reason I can't access my Transunion report?

Hurray!

But it still isn't going to help me refinance my home, which is what I thought all of this hassle was going to do! Grrrr!

But at last, FINALLY, Palisades is gone from my life forever!


lrhall41

Submitted by smo65d11 on Wed, 03/25/2009 - 07:53

( Posts: 1467 | Credits: )


pinch me!?? It happened!?? Palisdes is off Transunion finally!?? I am freeeeeeeeeee!
Let me just mention that this debt was set to come off in one year ...?? I had paid it in full, disputed it many times as such WITH a copy of the paid in full letter they sent me, but Palisdes insisted that I owed an extra $113 because the law firm that collected the debt kept back a portion.?? They had several violations and with a LOT of patience and a good attorney, they had to pay.?? I could have left it another year to come off on its own, but I decided it was the principal of the thing ... and won against them in court.??
If you think you have a case against a Collection Agency, send the information to a consumer rights attorney, and they will tell you if you have a case or not.?? You of course are never guaranteed a "win", but if the attorney offers to take it on contingency, you can bet that you have a pretty good case as they don't get paid unless you win!


lrhall41

Submitted by smo65d11 on Mon, 03/30/2009 - 07:05

( Posts: 1467 | Credits: )


fighting one company was enough for me!?? It took 2 years of me getting serious about my credit before I was able to fix everything ... well except for my 120+ day late on my mortgage 3 years ago!?? That unfortunately will stick with me for a full 7 years.?? But I will continue writing my goodwill letters to them every month, you never know what might happen!
??
All I can say is I followed the information that I found on this website and on the myfico website, and I went from having a dozen PIF's and a couple of lates, to just having the one UGLY late.?? Thank you to all of the posters and moderators on here for helping me and everyone else out there that is in the same boat!


lrhall41

Submitted by smo65d11 on Mon, 03/30/2009 - 07:34

( Posts: 1467 | Credits: )


Ya! I was coming in to see if it was finally off. My Transunion score went from 511 to 560 (and just mainly medical/and bankruptcy) still on my report.. I'm working on paying the Medical bills one by one.. and Bankruptcy i'm going to TRY and get off come Sept, but I doubt it.. WI is 10years. (But i'm gonna at least try I filed in 2002) by then I should have all my medical bills caught up.
Equifax is still ugly only because it's reporting a judgement from the state which I paid in 2003. I am trying to get that off my report as Transunion deleted it.??
I still am working on my Chexsystems report... I will have one paid off end of next month hopefully as it is small, and the big one will take a couple months.??
??


lrhall41

Submitted by beli2005 on Mon, 03/30/2009 - 10:08

( Posts: 882 | Credits: )


oh no, I am a DebtCC addict!?? You'll never get rid of me!
??
seriously I have changed my lift (as lame as it sounds) in large part because of this site.?? My FICOs in 2006 were:
??
Equifax 629
Experian 604
Transunion 527
??
Now they are:
Equifax 715
Experian 674-(this is from a couple of months ago before Palisdades came off, so it is surely higher now)
Transunion 702


lrhall41

Submitted by smo65d11 on Mon, 03/30/2009 - 10:44

( Posts: 1467 | Credits: )


Perhaps if you would all pay your debt, collectors wouldn't have to send you demand letters. I think it's sad that society believes that they can run up credit card bills, never pay, and then sue the people who try to collect what is rightfully owed [or less in most instances]. I have no respect for the lawyers who defend such unethical acts.


lrhall41

Submitted by on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 08:56

( Posts: | Credits: )


[quote]Perhaps if you would all pay your debt, collectors wouldn't have to send you demand letters. I think it's sad that society believes that they can run up credit card bills, never pay, and then sue the people who try to collect what is rightfully owed [or less in most instances]. I have no respect for the lawyers who defend such unethical acts. [/quote]

Perhaps if you were not a bottom feeder and breaking the laws you wouldn't have to worry about trolling in a debt repair forum and trying to put people down to make yourself feel better.


lrhall41

Submitted by Count_Vlad on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 08:58

( Posts: 356 | Credits: )


If collectors would send demand letters for accounts that they rightfully owned, not accounts they illegally pretend to own the rights to...argh...if they were the slightest bit ethical...if they wern't lying stealing, backstabing slime critters...
Yuk! Shame on you for trying to portray a know it all! Scum! Go away!


lrhall41

Submitted by IPoured on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 15:01

( Posts: 223 | Credits: )


You know, that's what kills me! The CA's thinking it's all the debtor's fault; the debtor just doesn't want to pay his/her bills.

Let me tell you, now I'm employed and I do want to take care of the bills I defaulted on WHILE I WAS UNEMPLOYED, not because I just didn't want to pay them, I have only been able to get one of them settled. The CA's that have the rest of them are so busy trying to screw around with me and play their CA games, they aren't getting paid. As a matter of fact, I'm suing two CA's for violating the FDCPA while I was trying, in good faith, to get them to validate the debts so I can pay them.

Now, it looks like I'll not only get the debts taken care of, at no cost to me, I'll also be getting a bit of money from these CA's for their troubles.

Works fine with me either way!


lrhall41

Submitted by FloridaRon on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 15:11

( Posts: 1190 | Credits: )


Me too Florida Ron! All I wanted was for the collection agency to reflect to correct current status of the debt I paid them on my credit reports. Noooo, they gave me the BIG run around, screwed me after I paid them by sneaking in a judgment against me for the debt I paid them, wouldn't fix it with the courts or credit reports, THEN they sold my paid in full debt to some other collection agency. WHAT A BIG x@*%! HEADACHE! Just paying your debts isn't as easy as it sounds know it all Guest. No respect guest guy says for lawyers that help out people who don't pay their debts, he need therapy! Thank god for these lawyers because the ONLY way I could fix the current status of the debt with the courts (I did this part myself) and to fix it with the credit reporting agencies was to have a god sent attorney SUE THEM RIGHT BACK!

By the way, my attorney just told me that I have a good case and should be hearing back from the collection agency AND the attorney for the collection agency regarding the settlment amounts! Also, I am promised that their negligence, dishonesty and unethical behavors will be remedied! GOOD RIDDANCE TO THEM!

One down 3 to go for me. Good luck to you too Ron!


lrhall41

Submitted by IPoured on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 16:55

( Posts: 223 | Credits: )


You don't know how happy I've been to find this forum. My mother just passed a few weeks ago and I've just been through so much lately. Worst comes to worst, I get a call from a creditor, which sounds like a a law office or something. I haven't contacted them back because I'm sort of afraid to. I have 3 kids to feed on a single income. I don't know what account they're calling to collect on, but I'm assuming it's old because I haven't had a credit card since I was 19 or 20 years old. I think they've been harassing my mother in law also, but she doesn't speak english. I don't have a detail of my credit report, just the free ones that I've ran a couple of months ago. I'm in California. Does anyone know the SOL for California? What should I do?


lrhall41

Submitted by on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 19:29

( Posts: | Credits: )


you do not have to give any info you do not want to give - you can post as a guest (though registering is still 100% private) and basically post what you did earlier here.. it will get more attention and you will get much more help that way. it is also more fair to the original poster of this thread.


lrhall41

Submitted by bea2ls on Wed, 04/15/2009 - 11:26

( Posts: 3840 | Credits: )


Anyone expecting their credit report to be updated overnight is a dope. It can sometimes take bureaus a week or two from the time it is reported to them until to the time it actually gets updated. The FCRA and FDCPA are designed to protect everyone but especially protect the least sophisticated consumer. You guys seem to fit that bill. Give the credit bureaus time to process updates and quit crying when they cannot get it done overnight. Anyone needing an overnight update is a fool.


lrhall41

Submitted by on Sat, 04/18/2009 - 15:09

( Posts: | Credits: )


You know, Guest, I'm sure it doesn't take "time" for a Creditor/Collection Agency and the Credit Bureaus to put derogatory information on a person's credit report. So it shouldn't take "time" for them to remove that derogatory information either! Especially when it's part of a settlement in order for said Creditor/CA to avoid having to go to court for FDCPA/FCRA violations!

Sure we might be "least sophisticated consumers" but I'd be willing to bet you're a "extremely least sophisticated collector!"

So go peddle your "poop" somewhere else, because we ain't buying it.

Idiot.


lrhall41

Submitted by FloridaRon on Sun, 04/19/2009 - 05:52

( Posts: 1190 | Credits: )


I have successfully filed against two debt collection companies. Enhanced Recovery Corporation and Peak Financial Services, LLC. ERC settled the day before the hearing, then paid the $1000. Peak Financial hired a local attorney and then filed a motion to dismiss in Small Claims. The judge laughed at the attorney and said there was no such thing as a "Motion to Dismiss" in small claims. I proceeded to give my testimony after establishing jurisdiction of the small claims court. The defendants attorney only attempted to pick on small inaccuracies in my filing, which the judge promptly ignored, or corrected.

After hearing what I said, the judge stated that I had indeed established that the small claims court had jurisdiction and authority to enforce the federal law, announced that Peak Financial had indeed violated the FDCPA and pronounced judgment in my favor for the $1000 plus court costs.

The attorney had a red face afterwards and asked for my phone number. I told him his client already had my phone number and that is why we were there in the first place. I told him they didn't need to call me, but to just mail a check for the total amount due.

Bottom line...you CAN win! But you have to have every detail in order. Make sure your dates/times are correct. Mention each violation in detail and give the specific section of the FDCPA it violates. Your homework pays!


lrhall41

Submitted by on Sat, 05/30/2009 - 14:05

( Posts: | Credits: )


This Thursday, May 6th I go to court @ 8:30am and look sooooo forward to it at this point. I rec'd a summons w/complaint on 9/8 to my residence, I was not home, so I had 30 days to answer. 10/1/09 I responded directly to Forster & Garbus:
I do not owe/own any debt from the yr. 2003
Provide me validation of debt - payments, interest, fees, late charges etc., & I would be happy to check my records.
------time went by, on 4/5/2010 I received a date to appear in court.

After over 6 months of no reply from Forster & Garbus to me it was a wait and see.

Considering I had a court date why not be a little prepared, I am not a legal minded person, it takes a genius to figure out legal terminology, but I am a CPA & do know numbers.

1.) Filed complaint with the FTC
2.) Advised my State Attorney General's Office of issue; this was prompted because of the issue recently that Forster & Garbus had in legal courts as a class action against them....Why not start another?
3.) Researched FDCPA & sites like this and joined lawyer sites for previous case and codes.
4.) First is SOL (if this were mine) they stated 9/9/03 and issued summons and complaint 9/8/09 - 1 day before the SOL date in NYS.
a.) Where did they get this date?
b.) Show me the proof - validate your claim, I sent the request.
5.) Prove this debt belongs to me
6.) LVNV is the collector:
a.) Complaint states I agreed to pay the debt...I did?? [COLOR=Red]I think this is a misleading statement?
[COLOR=Black] b.) They state the provided me proof of ownership of my debt & value...they did???? [COLOR=Red]Another misleading statement?[COLOR=Black]
c.) They were ambiguous in what it is that I supposedly had done...Read this and tell me what you think?
[FONT=Arial Black]On information and belief the defendant in person or through an agent made credit card purchases or took money advances under a credit card or line of credit account or promissory note/loan - which a copy was furnished to the defendent (they spelled it this way).
[COLOR=Red][FONT=Arial]Is this a loan or a credit card they are implicating me for?
[COLOR=Black] d.) They state they Duly Demanded....They did???[COLOR=Red] Prior notification of debt was never received by me. I promptly checked my credit report..no activity pertaining to LVNV, Providian or Froster & Garbus, I went back 10 years.

Not knowing really where to start and knowing that I do not owe this Phantom Debt & I have no relationship with this 3rd party who claims to "Own" the debt, doesn't Plaintiff lack standing?

Anyways I will go to court like a sheep being lead to slaughter and see what happens. If they could not validate this debt with me prior to court I am not to sure what to do. I have a VERY common name and have had several bottom feeders try almost the same thing, but nothing legal..any suggestions?

Thanks!
[/COLOR][/COLOR][/FONT][/COLOR][/FONT][/COLOR][/COLOR][/COLOR][/COLOR]


lrhall41

Submitted by ARUSS on Tue, 05/04/2010 - 12:18

( Posts: 6 | Credits: )