logo

Debtconsolidationcare.com - the USA consumer forum

FCRA and FDCPA violations

Date: Thu, 04/30/2009 - 16:29

Submitted by IPoured
on Thu, 04/30/2009 - 16:29

Posts: 223 Credits: [Donate]

Total Replies: 12


Can somebody please refresh my memory... Palisades is still reporting to all 3 of my credit reports that I owe a debt that was paid in full last September. I am suing Palisades and the lawfirm both for these violations. (Lawfirm - FDCPA 1692 e (8) and Palisades - FCRA 616 & 617) My attorney told me that FCRA 616 &617 (statutory claims) are only $1000 each. A total of $3000.

My question is about the FCRA violations. Why are they only $1000 each? I thought I read on the ftc website (and posted here by an informative member) that violations of the FCRA are now $3500. Isn't it $3500 (up from $2500) penalty per violation per credit report? Am I misunderstanding FCRA? (Smo where are you...lol.)

FYI - The lawfirm that represented Palisades is trying to contain all 3 violations between the two different lawsuits in to one $1000 violation, total. Ha! On top of all that, the lawfirm wants to settle the WHOLE thing for $400-500 bucks! (I said no, by the way)

Help me?!


I understand that FDCPA is $1000 max. FCRA I beleive is per violation. The latest is that my attorney and I are settling for these violations ($3000 worth) for $4500. The agreed. My share (check) is $1000.

I was just curious about the ftc penalty of $3500 (up from $2500) per violation (FCRA?) for false reporting to the credit bureau. I suppose it does not apply in my situation. It is all a bit confusing to me.


lrhall41

Submitted by IPoured on Sat, 05/09/2009 - 10:33

( Posts: 223 | Credits: )


I would most definitely say it does apply if you have repeatedly tried to get them to fix their errors and they have persisted in incorrectly reporting this on your credit. I would also include any actual damages--for example, have you been denied credit since that was paid off? If so, you could possibly make a case that their negligence has cost you in terms of real money, and that is where actual damages come in. Keep this in mind though--if your credit sucks, you would have a hard time showing that they were the reason behind you not being approved for credit. If you go this route, you will open up your credit reports as evidence, and if there is a lot of bad entries on them, the defense will use it against your claim for actual damages.

Me personally, I would not have settled for $1000, but hey, thats still a victory over a bad debt collector!


lrhall41

Submitted by on Sun, 05/10/2009 - 04:56

( Posts: | Credits: )


The penalty for the CRAs is a fine levied by the FTC. The $1000 for FDCPA violations is intended to encourage consumers to fight for their rights. You would also ask for court costs and attorney fees. You may possibly get more in damages if the DC was particularly harassing. I've seen cases where a jury gave the alleged debtor a half a million dollar damages, due to the fact that the alleged debtor was over 70 and it was not their debt but the CA wouldn't listen and wouldn't respond to DVs.

But, yeah, it's $1000 max. There is legislation to increase that amount, as that amount has been in place since 1977 when $1000 meant something, but it's still tied up in the Obfuscatory Chamber(!!).


lrhall41

Submitted by Chrys Henderson on Sun, 05/10/2009 - 23:00

( Posts: 2538 | Credits: )


Quote:

Originally Posted by IPoured
Can somebody please refresh my memory... Palisades is still reporting to all 3 of my credit reports that I owe a debt that was paid in full last September. I am suing Palisades and the lawfirm both for these violations. (Lawfirm - FDCPA 1692 e (8) and Palisades - FCRA 616 & 617) My attorney told me that FCRA 616 &617 (statutory claims) are only $1000 each. A total of $3000.
My question is about the FCRA violations. Why are they only $1000 each? I thought I read on the ftc website (and posted here by an informative member) that violations of the FCRA are now $3500. Isn't it $3500 (up from $2500) penalty per violation per credit report? Am I misunderstanding FCRA? (Smo where are you...lol.)
FYI - The lawfirm that represented Palisades is trying to contain all 3 violations between the two different lawsuits in to one $1000 violation, total. Ha! On top of all that, the lawfirm wants to settle the WHOLE thing for $400-500 bucks! (I said no, by the way)
Help me?!

Did you ever get clarity on this matter? Is it $1000 per incident, per report, per company? $3500 max or $2500?

I removed your email address, as our TOS here do not allow personal info like that to be posted in a thread. Thanks for understanding!


lrhall41

Submitted by on Mon, 04/12/2010 - 14:09

( Posts: | Credits: )