Share post
Debt Consolidation Forums Debt Consolidation and Debt Settlement forums

Debt Settlement vs. Debt Management --- need help to decide

member profile picture
Posts: 2
Credits: 0

Hi all ---

I just need some friendly advice. I have been mulling over whether to do debt settlement or management since March and, frankly, I can't keep dilly-dallying. So I was hoping to get some feedback to help me reach my decision. **Note: I know the difference between how both work, so I don't need advice on that aspect.

I am a married graduate student saddled with $23,000 in CC debt over several accounts (the largest is $6,500). We are getting nowhere with our debt and can barely afford the minimums. Also, in 2 years when I get out of school, I am going to have a boatload of student loan debt (~$60,000) on top of this.

When I first started looking into this, debt settlement looked viable - we could cut the debt in half and be CC debt-free by the time I graduate. But then it hit me - I will have six or seven collections accounts sitting on my credit report when I finish school. Even though they will say "paid in full," my credit score will be in the crapper and the hopes of getting a house in the not-too-distant future far, far away.

I went *this* close to signing with settlement - in fact, I was going to fax my signed documents tomorrow. However, upon reading the fine print, all the minuses hit me --- crappy FICO score, potentially sued, AND the fact that certain jobs may look at me badly and/or not hire me due to this delinquency.

As a result of this, I am thinking about switching to debt management. Lower interest rates and NO impact on FICO score. This seems to be the most sensible option.

So what am I looking for? If you have experience with either settlement or management, please chime in. I have looked for assistance before, but I find that a lot of advice comes from people who have never dealt with this. My questions are:

- Did you do settlement or management?
- How long did it take to finish (both)?
- Did you get sued? (settlement only)?
- How long did it take for your FICO score to go back up? (settlement only)
- How long did it take for the collections marks to get off your report (settlement only)?
- Did you have subsequent job, home-mortgage, or car insurance trouble due to settlement? (settlement only)

Thanks !!!


If you can afford the monthly payment for a debt management plan you should do it first. If you are overextended and can`t afford a dmp then you may want to consider Debt Settlement.

Sub: #1 posted on Mon, 08/18/2008 - 08:16

mobile0311 mobile0311
(Posts: 1817 | Credits: )

More information
  • Files must be less than 500 MB.
  • Allowed file types: txt pdf jpg jpeg png.

Page loaded in 0.733 seconds.