Debtconsolidationcare.com - the USA consumer forum

The difference between irresponsibility and circumstances

Date: Sat, 01/07/2006 - 08:03

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari
on Sat, 01/07/2006 - 08:03

Posts: 2192 Credits: [Donate]

Total Replies: 117


Hi everyone,

As I look thoughout this forum, I see other collectors stopping in as guests simply to lambaste the debtors in this forum, calling them deadbeats and scolding them for being debtors. Then they go on to defend the collectors being complained about in the forum, the ones who use illegal harassing tactics in the name of recovery.

Like I stated earlier, I did not crawl out from under a rock one morning, traipse into a collection agency and have a job handed to me. I know how the world functions. I approach each debtor with an open mind. After all, I don't know them from Adam, therefore I can't determine why they are in debt until I talk to them.

There is a great difference between being caught up in circumstances and being completely irresponsible. This something each collector must be aware of.

A perfect example of a very unique circumstance is the one being experienced by Mom of Twins, a forum member. She is a hardworking family woman who had been robbed blind, and then ridiculed by the original creditors. Now the collectors who call her are treating her like an irresponsible oaf! Where is the open-mindedness in that?

Statistically, I would say that roughly 25% of the debtor population are the truly irresponsible. The other 75% consist of people like Mom of Twins who have been ripped off, people who are newly disabled and have settlements pending, people who have been unemployed since their default date and still searching for gainful employment, and people who have disputes against the original creditors for reasons of their own.

A perfect example of an irresponsible debtor is the person I called yesterday. She had defaulted on a credit card. Why? Because she got pregnant and quit her job! She was not married, and had three kids. So she basically blew off her original creditor. This is the very definition of irresponsibility! People like this who do not think before they act, and who do not make sure all loose ends are tied before having children. Of course, she was angry with me for putting her on an affordable six month payment arrangement! This really is the limit of my compassion, people who do stupid things like this!

Another reason why this situation irks me so much is because, for the past 50 years or so, we women have been busting our **** to prove ourselves in society and in the workplace. Any woman who can take on the challenge of career and family, more power to you! But women who shirk financial responsibility in the name of motherhood, and possibly going on public assistance to boot, are disastrous to our progress in gaining full equality. It hasn't been attained yet! No female President yet! Still no equal pay for equal work!

Overall, sometimes everyone has huge problems to overcome, but shame on us if we create these problems for ourselves.

[color=Red]****Adult term removed - Jason[/color]


You're absolutely right! If you don't let loose and laugh a little bit you will snap!

As far as features go, yeah I look like my mom, but as far as stature and coloring go it's completely different. She has dark hair, dark skin, and she's short and stocky. I'm pale, blonde, and at 5'7" I tower over all the other females in my family. The man I'm married to is Scandinavian, he has white-blonde hair, and a blushed, round face. I keep calling him Bam-bam because of his resemblance to the Flintstones baby.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Wed, 01/25/2006 - 11:36

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Ari

I only saw a glimpse of Coca-Cola, are you thinking about chosing a career with them. Coca-Cola has actually violated their Vendor Code of Conduct, and we are no longer doing business with them.

Shirley

I remember when I was 16 or so, I would do what you mentioned...run into the store and buy food for them. Usually it was a fast, but healthy, meal. I guess it really depends on where I'm at, and how traffic is. I feel guilty sometimes, but sometimes I can only help so much.

Regards-
Mike


lrhall41

Submitted by Teleport on Wed, 01/25/2006 - 11:44

( Posts: 1388 | Credits: )


Mikey,
Don't knock what you did! All it takes is a split second to enrich the life of an unfortunate. What you did spoke volumes to these individuals. No need to feel guilty! You can only help so much? What exactly is your idea of helping more than "so much"? Mikey, reaching out to them is a wonderful thing and they are grateful for it. They're realistic, they know perfectly well that you can't reach into your pants pocket and pull out enough money for them to buy a house with. Give yourself a pat on the back!

I also said sour grapes to Coca Cola, they never contacted me. American Income Life has! I have my first interview Wednesday afternoon!


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Wed, 01/25/2006 - 11:54

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Ari

It was reported that Coca-Cola is/was doing improper waste disposal in India, and unethical labor pratices in Columbia. The University (where I work/attend school) gave them plenty of time to defend these allegations, and if response was not received, then the contract would be cancelled.

Pepsi still has a contract with us, but now we're getting Faygo.

Mike


lrhall41

Submitted by Teleport on Wed, 01/25/2006 - 12:06

( Posts: 1388 | Credits: )


Mikey,

Pollution and employee mistreatment are major sins in my book.
I'm looking forward to my meeting at American Income Life, this could be a new beginning for me.
Mikey, I just have to say that your little credo at the end of all your posts really communicates the very subject I've just been talking about. Us as a whole human race banding together and taking care of each other. It's really the only way to ensure the survival of humanity.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Wed, 01/25/2006 - 12:23

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Ari, good luck on the interview

Mikey, way to stay human and idealistic. Keep the faith (faith in the power of humanity to remember what it means to be human and humane.


lrhall41

Submitted by jj on Wed, 01/25/2006 - 13:08

( Posts: 1057 | Credits: )


Thanks JJ! I think the reason behind my feeble credit card and payday loan collection abilities is the fact that I cen see the people behind the numbers.

I can still tell the difference between irresponsibility and circumstances. Today I talked to a lady who I didn't even know was old until she said so. She went right back to work a week after having a hysterectomy, had five figure debts to credit cards and hospitals, and her hours got cut after the operation, and her husband only earns commission which right now is in the famine end of the spectrum. She told me they were looking at bankruptcy, and I said alright. Took her attorney's name and number, and wished her well. That's some resolve she's got! Going right back to work a week after major surgery! I had a similar procedure when I was 15 and it was too much for me to even get up and walk!

on the other hand, talked to a couple of senior citizens who didn't bother to tie up their financial loose ends before retiring! I didn't cut them any slack because that's a stupid thing to do!


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Wed, 01/25/2006 - 14:01

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Hello friends,

It's true that some people out there are so stuck in a situation that simply paying the bills becomes a delusion of grandeur. When it's the government that has a hand in our destruction, it's time to question authority!

I talked to a sweet old gentlman who could be anyone's grandfather today who owed a little over a grand to Walmart. He said he knew he owed the debt and once he found a job he would step up to the plate. THe poor old fella was living on a really stingy disability handout from the state that only covered his rent, medicine, and a little food. That's it.

What happened to him was, and this really gets my goat! He owned and operated his own successful trucking business, enjoyed excellent credit and lived moderately well. Then surprise, there is a new and stupid state law passed prohibiting anyone who is insulin diabetic from operating on commercial licenses. It all went downhill from there. He couldn't find anyone willing to cover enough of the driving to keep the business running, and he went under. What money he got from selling the business went to paying off business loans. Add insult to injury, one of my former colleagues was the first to call him and he was rude and condescending to him!

I'm still searching for an out because I can't do this anymore. Especially to good people like this man whose undoing was the work of the government.

Question authority, always.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Tue, 01/31/2006 - 15:39

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


That is so very sad, but I can see both sides of the insulin dependent driver with a commercial license. I am pretty confident that that particular law was passed as the result of a tragic accident where an insulin dependant truck driver was at fault. Someone who is having difficulty regulating their blood sugar can easily be mistaken for a drunk driver - poor co-ordination, slurred speach, just the classic drunk signals. (former cop - lol)


lrhall41

Submitted by Taquita on Tue, 01/31/2006 - 15:56

( Posts: 287 | Credits: )


I know what you mean, but I am guessing that the family of the victims really pushed for legislation to make the law happen. And I am sure, when you only hear one side (pro-legislation) and their particular story, it would be pretty easy to agree with them.

I have a great deal of sympathy for for the gentleman who lost his livelyhood.


lrhall41

Submitted by Taquita on Tue, 01/31/2006 - 20:29

( Posts: 287 | Credits: )


So do I, I feel deeply for my debtors. The honest ones anyway. Got a verbal kick in the shorts from management today for not meeting goal, being too conversational with debtors, and basically treating credit card debtors the same way I treated student loan debtors...like people for crying out loud. They want me to be demanding and not listen to whatever is going on with them. I'm not an abrasive person, I just don't possess that personality trait. When I confront people I walk softly because I can't stand to draw tears.
Whatever debt the honest people have, they eventually will pay, but not by blatantly disregarding their basic needs! No collector should commit almost a hate crime for the sake of a debt, that's like selling your soul for a doughnut.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Wed, 02/01/2006 - 19:20

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


You've got a point.

In fact, I went to an interview at American Income Life today. It is a job selling affordable health and/or life insurance. The bonus pay structure is really sexy, and as part of my pitch I can advise people to buy life insurance and disability insurance as a means to avoid the bill collector! How about that!


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Wed, 02/01/2006 - 19:44

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


It is a sales position, and if only my husband would be more supportive of my taking a commission only job I would be right on top of it. When it comes to commission only he's one of the biggest naysayers I know. But the personnel manager showed us recent sales figures, and a chart of how much can be earned if minimal effort is put in and its over $46K!
The schedule would also work for me, 12-9 Tuesday through Friday and a few late morning to early afternoon hours on Saturday. No more having to drag my grouchy ass out of bed at 6:00, I can sleep then do a little workout in the morning, still have enough time for school, etc etc. I really want to do it, but the personnel guy said it's not worth doing if my husband isn't going to be supportive. I still have my iron in various fires, soon I'll be out of the collection dregs.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Thu, 02/02/2006 - 17:51

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


What question you should be asking a debt collector who is taking you to court for a debt that he has bought from a company


lrhall41

Submitted by on Sun, 02/05/2006 - 01:39

( Posts: | Credits: )


Don't ask them anything. Just bring documentation, if you have been making small payments bring the cancelled checks or the money order receipts, if you've recorded conversations where a collector was breaking the law, bring that.
This is a debt that has been charged off by the original creditor and then sold to third party collections, and now you're being litigated? Why did you let it go this far?


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Sun, 02/05/2006 - 09:15

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Ari,

I don't know how you do it! You are such a sweet girl working in what seems to be such a cut-throat industry. I hope you find another line of work soon, considering that you have FEELINGS and all...good luck finding a new job, you know we are all rooting for ya :)

~Mary


lrhall41

Submitted by Mary on Sun, 02/05/2006 - 10:12

( Posts: 1344 | Credits: )


Mary,

The truth is, I barely do it. I was doing quite well with student loans since I felt a sense of purpose there. Here with credit cards and payday loans I'm in the manager's office every Friday getting chewed out for every reason imaginable that leads to my not reaching my preset goal. I dread having to drag myself to that office and plant my tuccus into that uncomfortable chair. I feel like I'm chained to that desk. It's dreadful. The only people who come to the phone are either decent people who are just broke, or degenerates hurling vulgarities in my general direction. The rest of the time I feel like a broken record leaving the same old-hat message on answering machines.
I have an interviwew coming up Wednesday evening. If I get it, it looks like my Marketing eduation and my year at Home Depot are opening a door. I'm also buying lots of yoga dvd's so I can stay in shape physically and mentally.
Everybody, your support of me mean worlds to me! You're my best friends!


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Sun, 02/05/2006 - 16:17

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Ari,

Yoga is one of my favorite things in the entire world. I never believed in being "centered" and all that nonsense, until I went to my first yoga class out of boredom. Now it has become a major part of my life! Keep taking care of yourself like that and you will definitely end up in the right direction.

I will be thinking of you and your new job interview~!!

~Mary


lrhall41

Submitted by Mary on Sun, 02/05/2006 - 22:33

( Posts: 1344 | Credits: )


I know what you mean! I love it too! I get more out of yoga than I ever did with weightlifting. The first dvds I bought are a Denise Austin yoga and a Susan Deason pilates. They are absolutely wonderful, and it??s such a treat to do it at home rather than have to drive to a class.
Right now, my husband and I are in Jacksonville preparing for out adjustment of status interview with the USCIS. It mean two days off from work, and a nice little roadtrip, just the two of us, to wrap up the whole green-card thing. Wish us luck on that too! Not that we need it, it??s all on the up-and-up!


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Mon, 02/06/2006 - 14:06

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Isn't a lot of debt a matter of an emotional decision made regarding finances, without regard for the ability to pay back what was borrowed?


lrhall41

Submitted by on Mon, 02/06/2006 - 14:24

( Posts: | Credits: )


Quote:

Isn't a lot of debt a matter of an emotional decision made regarding finances, without regard for the ability to pay back what was borrowed?


Mali, in some cases you are exactly right. People do make purchases on impulse without considering whether or not it's within their means. There are a lot of good people who have realized that, come to terms with it, and are here to get advice on how to get back on the right track. Yes, people do get laid off from their jobs often or have some unexpected circumstance. You might agree that the best defense is a good offense. Preparing for the rainy days, by keeping a used car with no payments as opposed to upgrading to a newer car that calls for an auto loan, or taking all extra money not spent on bills, groceries, and expenses and squirreling it away for protection in the event of a job loss, also taking the advice of a financial planner. With meticulous planning, many financial downfalls can be avoided.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Tue, 02/07/2006 - 15:14

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Ari, thank you for your comments. I have had nothing but harrassing phone calls from HouseHold Finance.. I tried working with them with a dmp but they refused, said they did not have work with me. I have always had GREAT credit, my husband started getting socked with 65% of his pay for past child support. We can hardly survive, I have cut out all the necessities worked with other creditors and am now in the process of working with HUD to hold onto our home. I tried working with Household, they were getting 260.00 a month, only 40.00 short of my monthly payment, they have been ruthless, all I'm trying to do is avoid bankruptcy, pay my bills, get my credit back in line. I have wrote letters to the Attorney General, Consumer Affairs, whoever will listen about Household. Everyone one else has been wonderful, I had a rep who was the most obnoxious person to walk this earth, she told me I was irresponsible I said how could that be when I called them! PS: I have 4 Cats... Hence the name Babs3Catz, the 4th cat was a surprise but I couldn't toss her into the cold. When I went to HUD they even took into consideration my animals if you can believe that one! Any help you can give me Ari would be greatly appreciated.. Thanks, Beth aka Babs3Catz....


lrhall41

Submitted by babs3catz on Wed, 02/08/2006 - 11:29

( Posts: 7 | Credits: )


Hi Beth, I'm glad you like reading my posts. I'm a realistic person and I'm fully conscious of reality around me. No matter what demand I'm told to make, I know you can't reach into you pants pocket and pull out a balance in full. As for the harassment and threats, it's all hot air trust me. It is true that collectors have bonus money to shoot for on top of their minimum wage and that's why they all get a wild hair across their ass when you ask for a little leeway so you can live. I would accept $260, I wouldn't say no to that! Heck, with four adorable cats I'd probably cut you a break at $200 even because cats just make me melt! Hats off to you for taking on a fourth, you my dear have a heart of gold!
Anyways, keep the attorney general, the better business bureau, and consumer affair nice and close you do need a support system. As long as you are paying as much as you are paying they can't legally sue you for garnishment of wages, keep that in mind. Also, you don't have to take that crap from that jackass at Household, don't be afraid of them, go right ahead and stand up to them. You are doing your part and paying monthly, go ahead and lay on a guilt trip about how they want bonus money to piss away on frivolties on the backs of people like you who are struggling. Also, think it through if you're considering sending them a cease and desist, it might just fan the flames as this can get your account moved then the whole farce starts over again. Get call blocking or something like that, think about changing your phone number to an unlisted one as well.
Keep me posted on everything. I want to know what some of these creeps say to you, if it' really bad just send it to my pm. I'd like to know what kind of account this is so I can better advise you. Also, I'd like to know more about your cats!
Thanks, Ari


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Wed, 02/08/2006 - 19:39

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


Thanks mamasita! And welcome to the forums! Feel free to pop in whenever you feel like and offer any advice or consolation to the forum members. They're wonderful people and it would be an absolute miracle if the collection industry would realize that. Then again, if they did we wouldn't be having this conversation. Every storm cloud has a silver lining!


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Sat, 02/11/2006 - 13:10

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


That is so cool that you are close to your mom, I am the same way with my mom! As a matter of fact, if she actually had a bit of debt, she would probably be here chatting with us right now! :) I am still trying to talk her into joining, since she does have a couple questions on credit reports and such....I'm sure she'll be here soon :)

~Mary


lrhall41

Submitted by Mary on Sat, 02/11/2006 - 14:02

( Posts: 1344 | Credits: )


My mother also concurs with my husband, future boss, and the forum members that working crap collections and terrorizing people who are down and out doesn't pay. She has no debts, but when I describe certain cases, anonymously of course, she understands that there is no reward to reap from people who have lost it all. To do so is predatory. Maybe the bonus check is an enticing incentive, but they're not important to me if they're not earned with dignity and honor. I refuse to be a charlatan, and my entire family respects that.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Sat, 02/11/2006 - 15:30

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )


What really caught me off-guard is the difference between collecting student loans and third-party collections. With student loans, the environment was very studious, upbeat, and professional. My manager encouraged us to use the fdcpa as a means to establish trust, build rapport, and build almost a business relationship with the debtors. My transition to third-party collections was culture shock. Unprofessional, negative, and harsh. Very little adherence to the FDCPA, and no rapport just demands. I would gladly go back to student loans, I loved it. But from here on out I won't touch third party with a mile long pole.


lrhall41

Submitted by Jedi Mistress Ari on Sat, 02/11/2006 - 16:51

( Posts: 2192 | Credits: )