This is embarrassing, but I recently paid BBM over $600.00 to settle a debt with 1st Savings. I argued that I had paid it before, but never received a paid in full letter. So, finally, I relented and paid it. I then checked my Franklin Planner and found notes from 5 years back where I did, in fact, pay for it. I even sent an email to a consumer law firm (never heard back) about this. I am wondering what to do know. I was thinking of sending a letter requesting the paid in full from the original firm and then demand payment back, or should I find another lawyer?